Restore Hayes Street to Public Use.
Sign the Petition

SFMTA

Week 71 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

April 20, 2026 Attention SFMTA: Past weekend closure conditions are as follows:Friday April 17, 2026Saturday April 18, 2026 No material changes were observed.Continued operation of this permit is difficult to justify. Accordingly, consistent with our prior correspondence, we again call on the SFMTA Board to revoke Permit No. 1316522. This correspondence has been edited for clarity and conciseness. Routine greetings … Read post

Week 70 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

April 14, 2026 Attention SFMTA: Past weekend closure conditions are as follows:Friday April 10, 2026Saturday April 11, 2026, the 400 block of Hayes Street observed open to public use Conditions observed this past weekend included: As noted in prior weeks, continued operation of this permit is difficult to justify. Accordingly, consistent with our prior correspondence, we again call on the SFMTA … Read post

Formal Administrative Complaint — Hayes Street (SFMTA) Shared Spaces Permit

April 10, 2026 Dear Director Kirschbaum and SFMTA Shared Spaces Management Team, We submit this formal administrative complaint regarding the administration of the Shared Spaces permit for the 400 block of Hayes Street, including sustained noncompliance, lack of enforcement, and related procedural concerns. This complaint is intended to establish a formal administrative record and to request corrective action. 1. Sustained … Read post

Week 69 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

April 7, 2026 Attention SFMTA: See closure conditions for this past weekend: Friday April 3, 2026Saturday April 4, 2026 Conditions were consistent with previously documented patterns, including: On Friday evening, a scheduled event (“movie night”) took place at Parcel K while the adjacent closure area remained largely inactive. On Saturday, a recurring vendor event occupied the closure footprint, reflecting continued … Read post

Week 68 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

April 3, 2026 Attention SFMTA: Closure Conditions Observed – Weekend of March 27-28, 2026Friday March 27, 2026Saturday March 28, 2026 Conditions observed this past weekend were consistent with previously documented patterns including: At this stage, these are not new observations. They remain ongoing and unaddressed. Efforts to characterize routine documentation of public street conditions as harassment have been rejected. Despite … Read post

Week 67 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

March 28, 2026 Attention SFMTA: Closure Conditions Observed – Weekend of March 20–21, 2026Friday March 20, 2026Saturday March 21, 2026 For more than 67 weeks, community members have systematically documented ongoing compliance failures associated with the Hayes Street closure. These records demonstrate a clear, consistent, and unaddressed pattern of violations. Observations from this past weekend reflect the same persistent issues: … Read post

Week 66 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

March 21, 2026 Attention SFMTA: See closure conditions for this past weekend:Friday March 13, 2026Saturday March 14, 2026 During Week 66 of monitoring, conditions observed were consistent with previously documented patterns, including:• Continued lack of consistent on-site monitoring and active barricade management during closure hours • Multiple instances of vendor activity, improper barricade placement, and lack of clear path-of-travel markings … Read post

SFMTA Correspondence: On-Site Operator Visibility & Engagement Concerns – Shared Spaces Permit 1316522

December 2025- March 2026This thread documents follow-up communications with SFMTA regarding practical challenges in community documentation of public street conditions during the Hayes Street closure. The focus is on clear identification of the on-site representative to support neutral, safe oversight. December 2, 2025 – Initial Email to SFTMA Shared Spaces Team We are writing to raise an operational concern regarding … Read post

Who Enforces a Permit in the Public Right-of-Way?

Over the past several years, residents and businesses have been repeatedly encouraged by SFMTA staff to document and report conditions, impacts, and potential violations related to the Hayes Street closure and the permit governing the use of the street. Many people have done exactly that. Photographs, written reports, and formal correspondence have been submitted documenting a wide range of concerns … Read post