A Temporary Permit. A Permanent Ambition.

On December 1, the SFMTA Board will consider extending the Hayes Street closure for another two years, through November 2028. While proponents continue to appeal to the public to help “save” the closure, their broader objective is explicitly stated in their own campaign materials: permanent pedestrianization of Hayes Street. There is a fundamental difference between supporting occasional community activities and supporting the permanent closure of a commercial thoroughfare. What began as a temporary pandemic-era accommodation has gradually evolved into a …

continue reading

Week 22 • Hayes Street Farmers Market Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1493851

November 15, 2026Attention SFMTA:Saturday November 14, 2026 Week 22 documents conditions consistent with prior weekly reports. Vendor participation remained limited, comparable to the previous week. The recurring Signature clothing vendor was again present, and numerous containers and market-related materials were observed occupying sidewalk space, raising additional concerns under the permit’s sidewalk-access requirements. These conditions continue to raise concerns regarding the market’s operation and its impacts on surrounding businesses and neighborhood access. Our October 19 request to relocate the farmers market …

continue reading

Week 101 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

Attention SFMTA:Saturday, November 14, 2026  Week 101. The street remained open to traffic on Friday due to rain, once again without advance public notice to residents or businesses. Saturday evening’s closure saw limited activity, while nearby Parcel K remained vacant. The contrast continues to raise the same question: why is a functioning commercial street being closed for recreational use when existing neighborhood spaces remain available? Our request remains unchanged: revoke Permit No. 1316522 and restore the 400 block of Hayes …

continue reading

Hayes Street Closure Renewal — Public Participation Concerns

November 10, 2026 Dear ISCOTT Members, Ahead of the upcoming Hayes Street closure renewal hearing, we believe it is important to place an additional concern regarding public participation on the record. Residents and small business owners have expressed reluctance to participate publicly because of concerns about potential repercussions. These concerns are particularly relevant given the civil harassment proceedings initiated by a board member of HVNA, the permit holder, against one of our members in connection with our documentation and public …

continue reading

Six Years Later, What Justifies Continuing the Hayes Street Closure?

For nearly six years, a temporary street closure on the 400 block of Hayes Street has been repeatedly renewed. Throughout that period, residents and merchants have raised questions about its impacts, operation, oversight, and long-term purpose. Yet the fundamental question remains unanswered:After nearly six years, what evidence justifies continuing this temporary closure, and under what circumstances would the City ever decide to end it? The issue is no longer simply whether some people enjoy the closure. The question is whether …

continue reading

SFMTA ISCOTT Public Hearing For Hayes Street Closure

November 9, 2026 Dear ISCOTT Members, Hayes Valley Safe opposes the proposed two-year renewal of the recurring Hayes Street closure. What began as an emergency-era accommodation in 2020 has continued for six years through successive annual permit renewals. For the first time, the permit holder is seeking a two-year authorization, extending the arrangement through November 2028 despite longstanding operational concerns, unresolved agency inquiries, documented transit impacts, and repeated requests for meaningful community engagement. After six years, the question is no …

continue reading

Week 21 • Hayes Street Farmers Market Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1493851

November 8, 2026Attention SFMTA:Saturday November 7, 2026 Week 21 documents conditions consistent with prior weekly reports. Only eight vendors were observed participating in this week’s market, raising further questions about the justification for an eight-hour street closure on an established commercial corridor. Our October 19 request to relocate the farmers market from the 400 block of Hayes Street remains outstanding and has not received a substantive response from SFMTA. This correspondence has been edited for clarity and conciseness. Routine greetings …

continue reading

Week 100 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

Attention SFMTA:Friday November 6, 2026Saturday November 7, 2026 This weekend’s observations included an organized Friday evening bingo event in the closed roadway, advertised by the permit holder with a designated host and merchant gift certificates. The event illustrates a larger concern that has remained unresolved throughout this permit’s history: a functioning commercial corridor is being removed from normal circulation to accommodate recreational programming organized by a private association, while existing public spaces in Hayes Valley remain available for such activities.  …

continue reading

Week 20 • Hayes Street Farmers Market Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1493851

November 2, 2026Attention SFMTA:Saturday October 31, 2026 Week 20 documents conditions consistent with prior weekly reports, reflecting HVS’s ongoing concerns regarding the market’s operation and impacts on surrounding businesses and neighborhood access.Our October 19 request to relocate the farmers market from the 400 block of Hayes Street remains outstanding and has not received a substantive response from SFMTA. This correspondence has been edited for clarity and conciseness. Routine greetings and contact details have been omitted; the substance of the communication …

continue reading

Week 99 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1316522 Noncompliance

November 1, 2026Attention SFMTA:Friday October 30, 2026Saturday October 31, 2026 Week 99.  Our request remains unchanged: revoke Permit No. 1316522 and restore the 400 block of Hayes Street to normal public use. This correspondence has been edited for clarity and conciseness. Routine greetings and contact details have been omitted; the substance of the communication remains unchanged. See all weekly notifications sent to SFMTA