Hayes Valley Entertainment Zone – Rules Committee June 2, 2025 Hearing

May 30, 2025 Dear Members of the Rules Committee, We write to raise serious concerns about the legislative maneuvering underway to codify Hayes Street as part of a permanent “Entertainment Zone.” What is being framed as a citywide policy is, in practice, a means of entrenching a deeply contested weekend street closure that has harmed small businesses, lacked public process, and repeatedly violated basic standards of transparency and accountability. You have all been included on the email thread with SFMTA, …

continue reading

Why We Keep Showing Up

A reflection on advocacy, frustration, and the failed policy behind the Hayes Street closure. We never imagined we’d have to fight this hard for fairness. Like many others, we simply cared about our neighborhood-its businesses, its streets, and the people who live and work here every day. But once the aim evolved to keeping the street closed, and the impacts on small businesses became impossible to ignore, we realized someone had to speak up. What followed wasn’t easy. We’ve spent …

continue reading

Hayes Street Closure: Bad for Business Worse for the Planet

A Street Closure That Fails the Climate, the Community, and Common Sense You’ve probably heard the pitch: closing streets is good for the environment. Fewer cars, more walk-ability, climate wins. But here’s what actually happens when the 400 block of Hayes Street is closed and why it undermines the very goals it claims to support. Let’s be real: Hayes Valley has always had traffic. It’s a dense, active, mixed-use neighborhood. But the current closure is not business as usual, it’s …

continue reading

Why You Should Care About What’s Happening on Hayes Street

Update (Dec 2025):This piece was originally published in May 2025. More than six months later, the issues raised here remain unresolved — and in many cases have intensified. Subsequent permit renewals, “activation” programming, and political messaging have reinforced the same pattern described below. Documentation Hub For the full record of the Hayes Street closure permit, monitoring logs, and policy analysis, see our Hayes Street Closure Documentation. Hayes Street is more than just a place to eat or stroll, it’s a …

continue reading

Immediate Action and Inclusion Demanded on Hayes Street Closure

May 22, 2025 SFMTA, SFCTA and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood: We write to follow up on our recent letter (below), which outlined urgent concerns about the Hayes Street closure…chief among them: ongoing noncompliance, lack of transparency, and the exclusion of the broader community from shaping its future. We’ve learned that an event has been announced for tomorrow, Friday, May 23rd, promoting Hayes Street as a “permanent pedestrianized Entertainment Zone.” According to the notice, the event will include live music, games, and …

continue reading

Week 20 • Hayes Street Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1091787 Noncompliance

April 28, 2025 Attention SFMTA: Road block conditions and permit violations for this past weekend have been documented here:Friday April 25, 2025Saturday April 26, 2025 {includes welding activity} Permit violations include but not limited to: We also want to notate that city property Parcel K/Proxy and Parcels R &S (Hayes Valley Art Works aka HVAW) sat idle while an event hosted by HVAW was insisted upon occurring on Hayes St.!  It’s incredible to bear witness to the ongoing land grab …

continue reading

Hayes Street Closure Activity April 26, 2025

Saturday April 26, 2025 11:35 am Adjacent Amenities: Patricia’s Green, Hayes Valley Art Garden Parcel S, Parcel K/Proxy, Linden Living Alley, Slow Page Street, Koshland Park, Page Laguna Park 5:20 pm