Hayes Street Closure Permit Noncompliance
LAST UPDATE: April 26th
The Gap Between Law and Practice on Hayes Street
For years, the conversation around Hayes Street has been framed as a question of preference…whether one supports it or not. But that framing misses something more fundamental. Because underneath the debate is a different question entirely: Is the current use of Hayes Street aligned with the legal and policy framework that governs street closures in California? What the Law Actually … Read post
HVNA and UCBerkeley Coordinated Study of the Hayes Street Closure Debrief
A summary of key findings, limitations, and omissions A group of UC Berkeley students produced a study comparing user behavior on the 400 block of Hayes Street under non-closure, closure, and event-based conditions. Closure supporters have cited the report as evidence that the street has become a “thriving public space.” The study was explicitly created “to support the long-term continuation … Read post
Who Enforces a Permit in the Public Right-of-Way?
Over the past several years, residents and businesses have been repeatedly encouraged by SFMTA staff to document and report conditions, impacts, and potential violations related to the Hayes Street closure and the permit governing the use of the street. Many people have done exactly that. Photographs, written reports, and formal correspondence have been submitted documenting a wide range of concerns … Read post
If the Goal Is Better Public Space in Hayes Valley, Let’s Talk About Real Options
For several years, the public conversation about Hayes Street has been framed as a simple choice:Support the street closure — or oppose public space. That framing is false. Many residents, merchants, and stakeholders have consistently supported the idea of improving Hayes Valley’s public spaces. What has been missing is a genuine willingness from City Hall and those shaping the current … Read post
Five Years of Transparency and Policy Analysis on Hayes Street
Understanding the process behind a critical neighborhood issue Responsible civic participation requires understanding how policy decisions are made — and explaining them clearly to the public. At its core, that means examining the process: how decisions develop and how policies are implemented over time. For the past five years, our coalition has focused on documenting and analyzing the decisions surrounding … Read post
When Enforcement Disappears, Fairness Disappears
Under Shared Spaces Permit No. 1316522, the permittee is responsible for ensuring: These are not optional guidelines. They are enforceable conditions of operation. Over the past year, we have documented repeated violations of these terms, including: When residents have attempted to inquire about permits in the past, operators responded with verbal hostility. As a result, neighbors now document from a … Read post
Hayes Street: The Pressure Point
At some point, it became clear that what unfolded in Hayes Valley was not really about a one-block street closure. If it were, the response would have looked very different. Disagreements over a temporary closure should not trigger years of exclusion, narrative control, retaliatory behavior, or institutional hardening. They should invite discussion, evidence, and course correction. Instead, the opposite happened. … Read post
A Record of Non-Engagement
From Campaign Support to Early Alignment This post documents our efforts to establish a working cadence with the District 5 Supervisor’s office in early 2025. It reflects contemporaneous correspondence from two neighborhood groups — Hayes Valley Safe (HVS) and the Hayes Valley Small Business Association (HVSBA). No interpretation is required; the record speaks for itself. The full email correspondence referenced … Read post
The Quiet Cost of Silencing Oversight
When a neighborhood association responds to routine civic oversight by reframing it as harassment, invasion of privacy, or harmful conduct, the issue is no longer about a street closure. It is about governance. In Hayes Valley, a private nonprofit administering activity on a public street under a city permit characterized ordinary documentation of public conditions as improper behavior. That response … Read post