Who Is Making the Decisions About Hayes Street?

The first two articles in this series looked at two different ways Hayes Street has been shaped. The Market & Octavia Area Plan established a long-term planning framework through years of public participation, environmental review, and coordinated decision-making. What followed years later was very different. Beginning with the pandemic, temporary programs, permits, renewals, events, and other initiatives gradually accumulated on Hayes Street. No single decision produced the street we see today. That raises another question: Who has been making those …

continue reading

What Happened After the Plan: The Evolution of Hayes Street

The Market & Octavia Area Plan established a long-term planning framework for Hayes Valley. As discussed in the first article in this series, Hayes Street was envisioned as an active neighborhood-serving commercial corridor within a broader strategy balancing transportation, public space, housing, and economic activity. More than a decade later, an entirely different circumstance began reshaping the street. An emergency changes Hayes Street In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic prompted San Francisco to introduce emergency programs allowing businesses and communities to …

continue reading

Before the Closure: The Market & Octavia Area Plan

For many discussions about the future of Hayes Street, it can seem as though today’s debates began with the Shared Spaces program or more recent proposals. In reality, Hayes Street has long been part of a broader planning framework adopted by the City. Before considering new concepts or permanent changes, the planning framework that already exists should be the starting point. The Market & Octavia Area Plan, adopted by the City in 2008 after years of public planning and environmental …

continue reading

The Entertainment Zone Is Here. Now What?

The Hayes Valley Entertainment Zone has entered its implementation phase. Following more than a year of correspondence and advocacy, we now turn our attention to how the program operates in practice. When Hayes Valley was added to San Francisco’s Entertainment Zone ordinance in June 2025, many residents and independent businesses learned of the proposal only after it was already advancing through the legislative process. Throughout the following year, Hayes Valley Safe participated extensively in the review process through correspondence, review …

continue reading

A Community Should Never Come to This

A Statement on Civic Dialogue in Hayes Valley The following statement was prepared after an informational poster explaining the Hayes Street closure was intentionally torn down within hours of being placed on the public sidewalk. While prompted by that incident, the statement addresses broader questions of civic dialogue, public participation, and the condition of community discourse surrounding the Hayes Street closure. This statement was distributed to San Francisco agencies and public officials and is published here as part of the …

continue reading

Taxpayers Footing Over $100,000 a Year for Hayes Street Closure Noncompliance

While SFMTA faces a $307- 322 million budget deficit, the agency continues to subsidize a street closure that delivers minimal public benefit and clear fiscal harm. Direct Costs to SFMTA and Taxpayers Combined direct cost: Well over $100,000 per year borne by SFMTA and San Francisco taxpayers — for a program riddled with noncompliance. These figures also do not include the Hayes Street Public Life Study, which public documents suggest will cost nearly half a million dollars and includes evaluating …

continue reading

Hayes Valley Community Center Update

For over 15 years, the Hayes Valley Clubhouse has been held out as a “community center.” In reality, it has never functioned as one. After being rebuilt with public funding and support, the space was handed over under a “temporary” nonprofit arrangement that has now stretched well over a decade. During that time, neighbors have had no reliable place to gather, meet, or participate in civic life without navigating fees, restrictions, or limited access. Now, with the current lease ending, …

continue reading

When the Rules Stop Mattering

For almost two years now, we’ve been telling City agencies about the same problem on the closed block of Hayes Street: vendors setting up shop without following the rules. It started back in June 2024. What began as one clothing vendor with a tent has turned into a regular scene: a big branded truck, sidewalk displays, and more vendors showing up. This isn’t a one-off anymore. It’s become part of the closure. The permit that closes the street says the …

continue reading

Hayes Street Farmers Market Conditions

400 Block of Hayes Street Hayes Valley Farmers Market Monitoring Beginning in June 2026, HVS commenced weekly monitoring of the Hayes Valley Farmers Market operating under Temporary Street Closure Permit No. 1493851. Reports document observed conditions, permit compliance, vehicle activity, parking pass usage, traffic conditions, public-space impacts, waste conditions, permit modifications, and other operational changes over time. For related correspondence with SFMTA, including our formal request to relocate the farmers market and outstanding inquiries regarding market-issued parking passes, see our …

continue reading