đź“‹ Closure Permit Status Update
November 20, 2025
We’ve issued a statement summarizing what occurred at the SFMTA Board hearing this week and our takeaways.
—> Read our full statement on the outcome
more updates to come
The closure of Hayes Street has affected small businesses, residents, and the whole neighborhood. But most people only know one side of the story.
This page gives you a quick overview — and links to more background if you want to explore further.
What You’ll Learn
How We Got Here
A “temporary” closure became permanent without community consensus. → Read the timeline
Impact on Small Biz
Retailers and service providers report decreased foot traffic, fewer sales, and economic harm — while bars and events benefit.
→ Read merchant stories
Who’s in Control?
The street is governed by a narrow group. → See how decisions are made
The City’s Role
Agencies like SFMTA haven’t enforced rules or upheld fair representation. → View the permit violations
October 2025 Update:
The City is currently reviewing the permit for the Hayes Street closure. A hearing was held on October 23, and final decisions about renewal or changes are expected soon.
→ Read our Statement
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Hayes Street closed?
The 400 block was closed in 2020 as a temporary emergency response to COVID. But the closure has continued for over 5 years — and now, Supervisor Bilal Mahmood is pushing for it to become permanent.
Who decided this?
The closure runs on a temporary permit issued by SFMTA. But the drive for permanence has come from the Supervisor, the HVNA, and a few select event organizers — not from inclusive neighborhood input.
Isn’t this just a pedestrian plaza?
That’s the image being promoted — but in reality, it’s a closed block with unclear management, frequent private events, and little oversight. Most small businesses nearby have not benefited and many have reported major losses in foot traffic.
What’s the concern?
Many small businesses report major drops in foot traffic and sales. Residents raise concerns about access, fairness, and who really gets to shape public space.
What do you want to happen?
We believe the street should be reopened to restore balance — and any long-term changes should come through an open, inclusive, and accountable process.
(Last updated: November 3, 2025)
đź“° Want More Background?
Behind the Scenes: The Push for Permanence → Why an “Impact/Feasibility Study” Can’t be Trusted
📬 Want to Stay in the Loop?
Sign up for updates or share how the closure has affected you.
We’ll follow up with a brief survey — and keep you informed.