A Temporary Permit. A Permanent Ambition.

On December 1, the SFMTA Board will consider extending the Hayes Street closure for another two years, through November 2028. While proponents continue to appeal to the public to help “save” the closure, their broader objective is explicitly stated in their own campaign materials: permanent pedestrianization of Hayes Street. There is a fundamental difference between supporting occasional community activities and supporting the permanent closure of a commercial thoroughfare. What began as a temporary pandemic-era accommodation has gradually evolved into a …

continue reading

Six Years Later, What Justifies Continuing the Hayes Street Closure?

For nearly six years, a temporary street closure on the 400 block of Hayes Street has been repeatedly renewed. Throughout that period, residents and merchants have raised questions about its impacts, operation, oversight, and long-term purpose. Yet the fundamental question remains unanswered:After nearly six years, what evidence justifies continuing this temporary closure, and under what circumstances would the City ever decide to end it? The issue is no longer simply whether some people enjoy the closure. The question is whether …

continue reading

A brief statement on civic documentation and public streets

BackgroundOn November 18, 2025, SFMTA renewed the permit for the Hayes Street closure. Three days later, a cease-and-desist letter was sent to an HVS member concerning our documentation of that same public street. That correspondence preceded civil harassment proceedings that were ultimately denied by the court on April 2, 2026. This page documents those proceedings and the broader concerns they raise about civic oversight, public scrutiny, and the ability of residents and small business owners to speak openly about decisions …

continue reading

A Community Should Never Come to This

A Statement on Civic Dialogue in Hayes Valley The following statement was prepared after an informational poster explaining the Hayes Street closure was intentionally torn down within hours of being placed on the public sidewalk. While prompted by that incident, the statement addresses broader questions of civic dialogue, public participation, and the condition of community discourse surrounding the Hayes Street closure. This statement was distributed to San Francisco agencies and public officials and is published here as part of the …

continue reading

Statement RE: How a “Temporary” Street Closure Became a Permanent Political Project

San Francisco’s Shared Spaces program was meant to help businesses recover. Instead, it’s been used to keep Hayes Street closed for nearly five years. What began as a temporary Shared Spaces closure on Hayes Street in 2020 should have ended years ago. By late 2023, SFMTA staff were prepared not to renew the permit — citing safety issues, merchant complaints, and the clear intent that Shared Spaces closures were never meant to be indefinite. That decision changed only after Supervisor …

continue reading

Our Statement

The Hayes Valley Entertainment Zone: The Story is Unraveling San Franciscans deserve transparent governance, not a backroom deal disguised as community policy. To those of you who have stood with us – thank you. Please keep sharing this with neighbors, small business owners, and public safety and good governance advocates. Over the past several weeks, we have uncovered internal emails, planning notes, and meeting records that reveal a coordinated effort by Supervisor Bilal Mahmood and his staff to deliberately exclude …

continue reading

Statement Regarding HVNA’s Involvement in Campaign Against Supervisor Dean Preston

Last month we informed you that Jen Laska, current president of HVNA (Hayes Valley Neighborhood Association) is concurrently on the payroll of GrowSF, a political action committee. The HVNA’s involvement with a political action committee presents a serious conflict of interest and compromises its credibility as a community serving association. HVSafe believes representation at the community level is critical and must not be tainted by partisan politics or personal agendas. The association has used its name to promote the agendas …

continue reading