On December 1, the SFMTA Board will consider extending the Hayes Street closure for another two years, through November 2028. While proponents continue to appeal to the public to help “save” the closure, their broader objective is explicitly stated in their own campaign materials: permanent pedestrianization of Hayes Street.
There is a fundamental difference between supporting occasional community activities and supporting the permanent closure of a commercial thoroughfare.
What began as a temporary pandemic-era accommodation has gradually evolved into a campaign to permanently change the function of a neighborhood street. Yet after nearly six years, the City has not articulated a clear pathway to reopening Hayes Street, despite longstanding objections from businesses and residents, 101 weeks of documented permit-compliance concerns, and an outstanding administrative complaint seeking revocation.
Why is the City continuing to facilitate an experiment whose proponents openly seek permanence, while those advocating for the restoration of regular street circulation have been afforded no meaningful process to advance that alternative?
At what point does temporary become permanent by default?
Hayes Street is a public roadway. Its future should not be determined incrementally through successive temporary permits.
The public needs to understand what is at stake.



