November 10, 2026
Dear ISCOTT Members,
Ahead of the upcoming Hayes Street closure renewal hearing, we believe it is important to place an additional concern regarding public participation on the record.
Residents and small business owners have expressed reluctance to participate publicly because of concerns about potential repercussions. These concerns are particularly relevant given the civil harassment proceedings initiated by a board member of HVNA, the permit holder, against one of our members in connection with our documentation and public scrutiny of the closure. The court ultimately denied the petition, but the impacts have been profound.
We believe SFMTA should be aware of the broader atmosphere surrounding this closure, where even expressing an opinion can carry concerns about personal and professional consequences. In a small neighborhood, these concerns can discourage people from speaking out altogether. As the City considers another two years, the absence of individuals from public hearings should not be mistaken for community consent.
Thank you.